The Canada Nation

Your Trusted news Source

Sorry, boomers, but falling home prices are good news for the country

Sorry, boomers, but falling home prices are good news for the country



Open this photo in gallery:

Cheerleading for higher home prices gave us peak unaffordability in 2020-22, and then a slow price decline that has been felt in Toronto and other cities, Rob Carrick writes.Lars Hagberg/The Canadian Press

The recent decline in home prices is great, right?

Boomers who are rich in home equity give a little bit back as prices fall, and doors open for young buyers currently priced out. When you consider all the anger about affordability here, in the United States and in Europe, lower real estate prices are almost a relief.

There are two types of measures or indicators that tell us how we’re doing financially – those where it’s good news when numbers go up, and those where we’re glad for declines. We all want economic growth and stock markets to go up, and we all want inflation and unemployment rates to fall.

Home prices have traditionally been in the “up is better” group, which is fair because owning a home is such a big financial commitment. Rising home equity is a validation of our choice to own, and it also builds wealth in a perhaps overrated way.

Can we now admit we got carried away with our cheerleading for higher home prices? It gave us peak unaffordability in 2020-22, and then a slow price decline that last month was felt in Vancouver, Edmonton, Toronto and Halifax, to name just a few cities.

Credit agency downgrades Canada’s housing forecast and sees another reason rates could rise

No one is expected to welcome news that their home is worth less, even though it’s just what this country needs to address the anger of people who feel robbed by inflation.

Two hotspots for unaffordability are food, where there is no hope of lower prices, and housing. We are seeing incremental progress on home prices. A recent report by National Bank Financial noted that we’re currently enjoying the longest streak of improving housing affordability ever recorded in Canada – 11 straight quarters.

That report is balanced by commentary last week from BMO Economics that included this line: “The housing market must still be regarded as ‘unaffordable.’” BMO says the typical mortgage payment plus utilities would account for upwards of 41 per cent of income, compared with the long-term median of 35 per cent.

Whatever affordability gains we’ve had so far are at risk from the increase in mortgage rates last month, which NBF describes as the largest in four years.

One way to keep pushing for better affordability is to build more homes at prices that young buyers can afford. The recent federal budget allocated money to help developers build 200,000 homes over the next decade, which highlights the fact that improving the housing supply takes time.

Budget’s housing commitments include tripling non-market options, new exemption to ban on foreign buyers

For now, price declines are the best hope for quick relief help on housing affordability.

Falling prices suit people who can’t afford homes, but what about current owners? Young people who bought at the peak a few years ago are suffering right now as a result of rising mortgage costs and declining prices. But they’ll be fine in the medium to long term as prices eventually rise again. Gen Xers also have time to recapture lost equity.

It’s boomers who feel the burn of lower prices the most – they have the biggest equity gains and an expectation of using that equity to help fund their retirement. But here’s something else boomers have – adult children who often feel priced out of owning a home and raising a family.

And so, boomers who can afford it are digging into their retirement savings to help their adult kids. In 2024, almost one-third of first-time homebuyers received parental help in the form of cash for a down payment, according to CIBC Economics. The average gift value was $115,000.

Lower home prices would ease the pressure boomers feel to give some of their savings to their kids, which would leave more money in parental tax-free savings accounts, registered retirement savings plans and registered retirement income funds.

This company wants to connect buyers with discounted condos – if they sign an NDA

Boomers would have less home equity to draw on in retirement if prices fall, but they will still be well positioned. Canadian Real Estate Association numbers show the national average home price in September was $666,538, compared with $164,454 in 2000. That’s roughly 5.5 per cent a year in price gains, which is more than double the average 2.2-per-cent inflation rate since 2000.

Boomer-owned homes were never going to retain their peak-of-the-market values, and they’ll undoubtedly recover at least some recent losses over time. Another thing to remember about boomers is that lots of them love their homes and are in no hurry to downsize.

Today’s boomer dilemma: higher house prices for my retirement or declines to help my kids? The latter choice is the most affordable for all.


Rob Carrick is a personal finance expert and former Globe and Mail staff columnist.