
Quebecor president and CEO Pierre Karl Péladeau addresses the media company’s annual meeting in Montreal in May, 2019.Paul Chiasson/The Canadian Press
Pierre Karl Péladeau is doing Canadians a big favour.
The president and CEO of Quebecor Inc. is putting the federal government through its paces on competition policy by way of his company’s $31-billion offer to buy larger rival Telus Corp.
Although Quebecor’s bid is rife with regulatory risk, its proposed combination with Telus exposes the increasing tension between Ottawa’s desire to foster national champions to fortify economic sovereignty and enforce competition law to promote market choice for consumers.
Regardless of the deal’s probability of success, Quebecor’s takeover offer for Telus forces the federal government to publicly interrogate the assumption that encouraging new national champions would create prosperity for all Canadians – and not just businessmen like Mr. Péladeau, whose family controls Quebecor through a dual-class share structure.
This is a national debate that is long overdue and one that ought to involve ordinary Canadians in addition to business leaders, lawyers and legislators. Until now, such policy deliberations have been superseded by the need for an urgent government response to economic coercion by the United States, including on matters of digital sovereignty.
But as Prime Minister Mark Carney takes action to shore up Canada’s economic sovereignty, his government must be transparent about the future role of competition law in telecommunications and every other economic sector.
Opinion: Like Rogers-Shaw, a Quebecor-Telus deal needs to sell Freedom, too. But it won’t be enough
That antitrust dialogue was already underway in legal circles. Quebecor’s bid for Telus brings it into mainstream discourse.
Prices for telecom services are secondary considerations relative to those for housing, food and transportation. But they remain kitchen-table issues. Every dollar counts.
“Canadian consumers have already seen the positive impact of Quebecor’s approach on competition,” the Montreal-based company stated in its release announcing its bid for Telus.
Quebecor’s brands include Videotron, Freedom Mobile and Fizz.
Let’s give Mr. Péladeau credit. Quebecor’s 2023 acquisition of Freedom Mobile has put downward pressure on wireless prices.
Of course, quantifying it depends on the selected measurements. Companies naturally pick self-serving metrics and the government is motivated by political haymaking.
With that in mind, Ottawa recently cited an example suggesting that a 60-gigabyte data plan previously priced at $105 in 2022 now costs $40 to $50. (Great, but unlimited data plans ought to be the focus in a 5G world.)
Quebecor argues that a new combined entity would provide Canadians with “a stronger competitor, capable of investing more, while continuing to offer wider choice” in part by maintaining Telus’s brands.
In addition to its signature mobile offering, the Vancouver-based telecom’s brands include Koodo Mobile and Public Mobile.
“Quebecor believes all Canadians will benefit,” it added.
Telus, meanwhile, is conducting a strategic review of all its options.
With respect to Quebecor’s proposal, Telus’s statement points to regulatory roadblocks and governance concerns, while also implying the deal’s financial terms need finessing.
Opinion: A Quebecor-Telus merger would be a problem for the industry – and for democracy
The Competition Bureau will likely be preoccupied with “structural presumptions” in the law suggesting mergers that substantially increase industry concentration hurt consumers.
Industry Minister Mélanie Joly, who will also assess the deal’s merits, was mum on the government’s long-standing four-carrier policy.
Four carriers in each market always seemed arbitrary. Even so, Ms. Joly will need to justify any potential policy pivot.
Quebecor’s offer for Telus, whether it succeeds or fails, should finally end its preferential treatment as a new-entrant wireless carrier. It has benefited from that status for nearly two decades, including through the government’s spectrum policies. (Spectrum refers to the invisible radio waves that carry wireless signals that are owned by the Canadian public and licensed to carriers.)
It was always questionable why an established regional player like Quebecor required generous implied taxpayer subsidies through federal auction policies over the years.
Now that Quebecor claims to have the financial wherewithal to acquire Telus, an incumbent carrier, it no longer requires any special treatment from Ottawa.
Analyst Adam Shine of National Bank Financial said in a research note that Quebecor “has been the poster child of the government’s competitive efforts, and it would now be the one calling for a reversal.”
Quebecor previously used its new entrant status to purchase 294 wireless licences of 3500 MHz spectrum, prime 5G airwaves, across the country. Still, its expansion of Freedom Mobile has hinged on piggybacking on existing networks.
What will happen to Quebecor’s 3500 MHz licences if it succeeds in acquiring Telus? Allowing the combined entity to keep them would rankle Rogers Communications Inc. and BCE Inc.
Ottawa has a history of scuttling attempts to transfer new entrant spectrum to large carriers – ask Telus about its three failed attempts to purchase Mobilicity. Indeed, the government is still fighting a related legal battle over an arbitrary change to its spectrum transfer rules in 2013.
Quebecor’s bid for Telus necessitates a belated public debate of all these issues. Canadians owe Mr. Péladeau a debt of gratitude for forcing the government’s hand.
Some telecommunications analysts are casting doubt that a proposed merger between Quebecor Inc. and Telus Corp. would be able to clear all regulatory hurdles and make it to the finis…
More Stories
Hedge funds exit a lucrative trade on Quebecor and Telus
Joly, Stellantis CEO to meet Friday in attempt to save Brampton plant
Nvidia forecasts quarterly revenue above Wall Street estimates, providing relief for investors