Toronto Maple Leafs’ Easton Cowan (53), left and Gavin McKenna (right) have gone from Memorial Cup opponents to NHL teammates, just over a year after the two faced off for a CHL championship.Sammy Kogan/The Canadian Press
As the losses mount in what is rapidly becoming another lost season for the Toronto Maple Leafs, the uncertainty over the future of Auston Matthews, William Nylander and other veterans will soon begin to slide into view.
But as an anxious fanbase starts to consider the next iteration of its team, it might want to look to the 2025 cup final for a hint as to what comes next. Not the Stanley Cup final, where the Florida Panthers cemented their legacy with a second straight title, but in the championship game of the sport’s junior ranks, where two of the foundational pieces of the Leafs’ future went toe to toe. Not that either necessarily knew it at the time.
“It’s pretty crazy obviously,” says Easton Cowan, the 2023 first-round draft pick who scored the winning goal as the London Knights beat the Medicine Hat Tigers to lift the Memorial Cup. The Tigers, of course, were led by Gavin McKenna, who was still a year away from being taken with the first overall pick by Toronto this past June.
“You’re not in that game thinking this might be your teammate in the next few years,” McKenna says, adding that they knew each other from playing for Canada at the world juniors. “You obviously just want to beat him at that time.”
The pair led their respective teams in playoff scoring in guiding them to the Memorial Cup tournament: McKenna putting up 38 points in 16 Western Hockey League games, while Cowan had a point more across 17 Ontario Hockey League contests.
Cathal Kelly: The Leafs keep dodging reality even after eight straight losses
And they’d done much the same in Rimouski, Que., where the 2025 tournament was held. Cowan registered seven points in five games to share the competition lead and ultimately winning the Most Outstanding Player Award; McKenna had six in four.
Those virtuoso performances established them as the beating hearts of their hockey clubs, with the rest of the roster looking to them to carry the load.
“He just takes over a game; it’s unbelievable, really,” says Landon Sim of Cowan. A fellow draft pick of the Leafs who also played for the London Knights, Sim teamed up with Cowan again with the Toronto Marlies for last spring’s run to the Calder Cup.
Sim mentions Cowan’s highlight-reel spin-o-rama pass in the OHL finals – where he set up teammate Kasper Halttunen for a decisive goal – as one such moment.
Easton Cowan celebrates with his London Knight teammates after they won the 2025 Memorial Cup. The win came at the expense of Cowan’s future pro teammate, Gavin McKenna, and the Medicine Hat Tigers.Christopher Katsarov/The Canadian Press
“He would put the team on his back at times and come through for us,” Sim says.
That sort of talent didn’t appear by accident. According to Knights general manager and co-owner Mark Hunter, one of the foundations of Cowan’s ability is his willingness to constantly work at his craft, just as he did after getting sent to Junior B as a 16-year-old.
Calling him a “hockey junkie,” Hunter praises his level of preparation and dedication, which contributes to the conditioning that allows him to hound the puck carrier constantly whenever he’s on the ice.
It’s a dogged trait that has seen him land on the Leafs’ top line this season alongside Matthews, and has enabled him to place fourth on the team with 17 points in 23 games.
Cowan’s characteristics remind Hunter of former Knights star Mitch Marner, whom he also had during his three seasons as assistant GM of Maple Leafs between 2015-18.
Worst homestand in Leafs history prompts John Chayka to face the music
“Mitch had the same engine. They don’t get tired,” Hunter says. “It just pushes your team to play faster, and he wants to play faster.”
Many of McKenna’s former teammates were equally gushing about their own talisman, marvelling at his vision, intensity, confidence, as well as his polite demeanour.
Unlike Cowan, McKenna didn’t get sent to Junior B when he arrived in the CHL. But Oasiz Wiesblatt, who played with McKenna for three years and captained the team in the Memorial Cup, says he wasn’t exactly wowed when he first clapped eyes on the-then 14-year-old in 2022.
“He was probably 140 pounds, soaking wet,” says Wiesblatt, who now plays for the Milwaukee Admirals in the AHL. “And you looked at the guy and you’re like, ‘What the heck are we doing here? Like, are you sure he can play?’
“You stepped on [the ice] the first practice with him, you knew what he was going to do, and it was something you’d never seen before.”
McKenna (left) was already drawing buzz as a No. 1 pick when he faced Easton Cowan and the London Knights in the 2025 Memorial Cup final. The Maple Leafs took him first overall in the 2026 NHL draft.Christopher Katsarov/The Canadian Press
His preternatural ability on the ice didn’t give him any airs and graces around his teammates off the ice though. Former teammate Tanner Molendyk, who got traded to the Tigers a few months before the Memorial Cup, said he thought McKenna would “be a robot, but he turned out to be a great dude,” adding, “Gav is as normal as they come.”
It’s an opinion that Wiesblatt backs up, adding that McKenna is so polite it almost throws you off.
“It’s pretty incredible how someone so skilled and so gifted in life can be a good human too, and not just be a cocky bastard in a way,” he says. “He was a guy who cared about everyone in the room.”
Tigers head coach Willie Desjardins says that although McKenna may have been polite and unassuming, when it comes to his ability, he puts him in a select class alongside the likes of current Maple Leafs centre John Tavares, whom he coached at the world juniors, or Daniel and Henrik Sedin, who played for him while he was behind the bench for the Vancouver Canucks.
“I think Gav’s vision is as good as anybody I’ve ever coached,” Desjardins says.
Though he managed to score in what turned out to be a 4-1 loss to London in the 2025 Memorial Cup final – and had a second goal ruled out for a high stick – his head coach said “he probably shouldn’t have played,” owing to a serious injury he picked up in the WHL finals, “but his drive to play was incredible.”
It’s that drive that sets players like McKenna apart, Desjardins said, and it is something that will stand him in good stead as he continues his career in Toronto. McKenna has already had to ride out his share of controversy during his rookie career, getting stapled to the bench at times and managing 14 points in 24 games – tied for sixth on the team – despite playing mostly on the third line.
“All the great players are the same,” the coach says. “They can’t take being average. It’s not in them to do that. So whatever happens, he will be trying to find a way to get better in whatever way that looks. He’s not gonna be satisfied with just being an okay player.”
It’s a trait that McKenna and Cowan both share, and something that the Maple Leafs can keep in mind however they decide to proceed given the hole they’ve dug themselves just past the quarter mark of the NHL season.
Though McKenna could understand it if Cowan wanted to chirp him about last year’s Memorial Cup final – “He’s not really a guy to chirp, but if he was, I’m sure he’d give it to me about that” – the two seem to enjoy a supportive relationship, occupying lockers either side of Colton Sissons at the Maple Leafs practice facility.
“It’s nice having a young guy to kind of hang out with,” McKenna says. “… and we’re looking forward to playing together for hopefully the rest of our careers.”
More Stories
Morrissey nets OT winner as Jets top Islanders 4-3
The Leafs keep dodging reality even after eight straight losses
Senators squander lead as Flyers earn 6-5 OT win