The Canada Nation

Your Trusted news Source

Eco-friendly trees for a greener Christmas

Eco-friendly trees for a greener Christmas



Open this photo in gallery:

Artificial Christmas trees have an understandable appeal. They don’t shed needles, require watering or drip sap on the rug. Some even come pre-strung with lights. The downside of the convenience, however, is a steep environmental cost. Most are manufactured from hard-to-recycle petrochemicals like PVC and are shipped from across the world. Compared to real trees, the ersatz ones are three times more carbon-intensive and tend not to be biodegradable, so end up languishing in landfills.

Johan Foster, a professor of chemical and biological engineering at the University of British Columbia, says there are ways to respect the earth and have a festive fake, too. “When you’re talking about plastic trees, making them out of recycled materials helps,” he says. The type of plastic also matters. “Polypropylene and polyethylene, which are used to make things like milk or yogurt containers, are easier to recycle than PVC,” he explains.

Pre-strung lights might not be the brightest idea. “They are a bit like a TV with a built-in VCR,” he says. “When one component breaks, the whole thing tends to be replaced. And the more materials that are integrated together to make the tree – plastic, metal, wiring for lights – the harder to separate those materials out and recycle them at the end of their lives.”

Ultimately, throwing out a tree because the lights are on the fritz could undermine a key requirement of sustainability: longevity. “Artificial trees are similar to reusable shopping bags,” says Prof. Foster. “The more they are used, the lower their environmental impact.”

Shannon Proudfoot: A mother’s secret to Christmastime joy: A tree of one’s own

According to different studies, someone would have to keep their artificial tree for 20 years or more to match the carbon footprint of a real tree. In North America, the average person uses their tree for six to 10 years. To prevent premature deterioration, Prof. Foster suggests keeping the boughs out of bite range for dogs or cats, storing them properly and protecting them from UV light, which tends to degrade plastic.

Becca Kram-Dos Santos, a spokesperson for the David Suzuki Foundation, agrees that longevity matters. “The greenest option is using what you already have,” she says. “So, if you already own an artificial Christmas tree, there’s no need to replace it simply because it’s made from PVC. Keeping it in use for as many years as possible, repairing it when needed or passing it along to another household can help reduce its environmental impact.”

That said, for those looking for something new, there are lots of options beyond plastic, including paper and recycled cardboard. “These materials can also be easier to recycle at the end of their useful life,” says Kram-Dos Santos, “provided they haven’t been treated with glitter, plastic coatings or other non-recyclable decorations.”

Looking for toasty winter socks? Invest in a pair made from natural fibres

Wood or fabric trees can also work. “Trees made from reclaimed wood, salvaged branches or responsibly sourced timber can be durable, long-lasting alternatives to plastic,” says Kram-Dos Santos. “For yarns or fabrics, natural fibres may offer advantages over synthetic alternatives, but the overall impact depends on how the fibres were produced, whether they’re blended with other materials and how long the finished tree lasts.”

Beyond sustainability concerns, Dos Santos points out that both artificial trees and real ones can be prohibitively expensive. Getting crafty or improvising can help save money and the planet. “A festive arrangement of fallen branches, a tree made from stacked books or a handmade creation using reclaimed materials can be just as beautiful as a conventional Christmas tree,” she says. “Stringing LED lights and decorations on a larger houseplant you already own is a low-impact and green way to bring that festive vibe into your home.”

When looking for a truly green Christmas tree, consider options that are made from natural, sustainable or recyclable materials.

Six buys to try

Oncor Trees

Open this photo in gallery:

Oncor produces artificial trees using recycled plastic and also tries to ensure the trees themselves are recyclable. Many of the components including the box, stand and trunk are made from uniform materials or can be separated and sorted for reuse. From $59. Available through oncortrees.ca.

West Elm

Open this photo in gallery:

West Elm’s Decorative Paper Floor Trees are ideal for people who neither want the hassle of sweeping up errant spruce needles, nor the eco-guilt of a plastic pine. The lightweight accordion structure is easy to unfurl, set up, then pack away at the end of the season. It comes in two sizes: three feet or seven feet. From $254. Available through westelm.ca.

Crate and Barrel

Open this photo in gallery:

The Warm Acacia Tannenbaum Christmas Tree is made from wood certified by the Forest Stewardship Council – a non-profit that vets tree growers for high environmental and labour standards. The boughs swivel around a wrought-iron trunk for a customized set-up. From $149. Available through crateandbarrel.ca.

Jomo Studio

Open this photo in gallery:

Many potted pine trees don’t adapt well to indoor living, but the Norfolk Island Pine is from the tropics and used to warmth and humidity, so it does well inside year-round. At Christmas, its conical shape is ideal for ornaments and lights. From $30. Available through jomostudio.com.

Obakki

Open this photo in gallery:

Handmade by a collective of female artisans in Querétaro, Mexico, the Handwoven Holiday Tree is a true showstopper. The raw cotton is both biodegradable (so won’t clog a landfill) and beautiful, with fringes that provide a fabulous texture. Tabletop and floor versions are available. From $495. Available through obakki.com.

Décors Véronneau

Open this photo in gallery:

Quebec-based Décors Véronneau produces its Eco-friendly Christmas Tree from recycled pop bottles. Each one has more than 1,200 individual tips for all the trimmings. It comes in 5-foot and 7.5-foot options. From $400. Available through veronneau.com