The Canada Nation

Your Trusted news Source

Carney mum on whether Ottawa would allow telecom sector to lose a national player

Carney mum on whether Ottawa would allow telecom sector to lose a national player



Open this photo in gallery:

Montreal-based Quebecor has proposed buying rival Telus in a deal worth $31-billion.Christinne Muschi/The Canadian Press

Prime Minister Mark Carney is refusing to say whether his government would accept Canada losing one of four national telecom players after Quebecor Inc.’s proposed takeover of Telus Corp.

But he said there are circumstances in which there can be more competition with fewer players.

The Canadian market for cellphone and internet services is an oligopoly, where a few companies control most of the business, and Ottawa has long made four national telecom carriers an explicit goal of its government policy to generate sufficient competition.

Speaking to reporters in Shenzhen on Wednesday, Mr. Carney declined to reveal his thoughts on the possibility of Canada’s telecom sector contracting to three national companies.

“I’m not going to make a direct comment about the number of players in the market, which would necessarily imply a conclusion about any specific transaction,” the Prime Minister said.

But he said his government will always favour more competition and lower prices.

“When push comes to shove, on any decision, if we can have more competition, lower prices, better service for Canadians – that’s where we’re going to land.”

Open this photo in gallery:

Prime Minister Mark Carney declined to comment on Quebecor’s bid to acquire Telus at a press conference in Shenzhen, China, on Wednesday.Florence Lo/Reuters

An economist by training, Mr. Carney added that he believed, under certain conditions, there can be more competition with fewer companies in an oligopolistic market.

“Depending on the market structure, the form of oligopoly can lead to more competition with fewer players under certain circumstances,” he said.

“It depends on the market structure aspects.”

On Tuesday, Quebecor announced a $31-billion proposal to acquire rival Telus, a takeover that would remake the cellphone sector and pose the second major test of the federal government’s competition law in the past five years.

Montreal-based Quebecor, led by media and telecom mogul Pierre Karl Péladeau, is offering to acquire Vancouver-based Telus, the country’s second-largest telecom by market capitalization, for $19.45 per share, in cash and stock. Telus’s share price has slid by more than 40 per cent over the past year.

Mr. Carney said the Competition Bureau and the Canadian Radio-television and Telecommunications Commission will undertake their reviews of the deal “depending on how any transaction unfolds.”

He also the government is revising its telecom policy right now.

“In parallel, we are in the process of updating our perspective on the broader telecom services market,” Mr. Carney said, citing technological change and “potential changes in market structure.”

He said the goal will also be “best service for Canadians at the most competitive prices today and in the future.”

Asked whether the threat of foreign competition such as Starlink satellite internet will affect the structure of the Canadian telecom industry, the Prime Minister said developments such as this are pushing down the costs of broadband for customers.

“We have seen the costs, for example, of broadband come down significantly over last years, but technological development, including some of the ones you’ve referenced, has the potential to further that progress.”

With files from Irene Galea and Andrew Willis