The Canada Nation

Your Trusted news Source

Quebecor’s bid for Telus is bad for Canada. The CEO himself said it

Quebecor’s bid for Telus is bad for Canada. The CEO himself said it



Open this photo in gallery:

Quebecor promises about $160-million a year in operating savings and $235-million in capital efficiencies, but cost savings for shareholders do not justify less competition for customers, Dwayne Winseck writes.Christopher Katsarov/The Canadian Press

Dwayne Winseck is a professor at Carleton University’s School of Journalism and Communication and director of the Global Media and Internet Concentration Project, which is supported by the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council of Canada.

In March 2021, Quebecor chief executive Pierre Karl Péladeau told the House of Commons industry committee that Rogers’ takeover of Shaw would take wireless competition “back to square one.” He rested his case on five words: “few players means less competition.” Quebecor later reminded Ottawa that Bell, Rogers and Telus “already control 90 per cent” of the wireless market. He was right.

This week, Quebecor made public an unsolicited, non-binding proposal to buy Telus for about $31-billion in cash and shares. If it succeeds, the fourth national carrier policy that successive governments have nurtured would be dead.

Quebecor has benefitted from that same policy to create a significant place for itself in Quebec and to expand across much of Canada after it acquired Freedom Mobile from Rogers-Shaw in 2023. That spinoff of Freedom Mobile was the price Rogers-Shaw had to pay to get regulatory approval for the takeover. Quebecor has built on that success and has used the Canadian Radio-television and Telecommunications Commission’s wholesale access regime for internet access and cable services to become a formidable fourth national telecoms operator across much of Canada.

If its bid for Telus goes ahead, four national carriers would become three, with Quebecor pulling up the ladder that it benefitted so much from, and at the expense of Canadians. The new company would be Canada’s largest wireless provider on day one.

Mr. Péladeau says a combined Quebecor-Telus would invest more, save hundreds of millions of dollars a year and help a Canadian-controlled champion stand up to global tech giants and satellite operators. Telus’ chair, John Manley, says Quebecor has yet to explain how the deal could clear Canada’s telecom rules. The numbers and experience suggest it can’t, and shouldn’t.

Under successive Liberal and Conservative governments since 2008, federal policy has aimed at one thing in wireless: a fourth carrier strong enough to rein in Bell, Rogers and Telus. But this policy has long been frustrated as most of the same new entrants that it encouraged, such as Public Mobile, Mobilicity, and Wind, were scooped up by incumbents within a few years. In contrast, Quebecor offers one of the few remaining success stories of that policy with its Vidéotron in Quebec and, since 2023, its Freedom Mobile in Ontario, Alberta and British Columbia.

These successes matter. The CRTC has found that prices fall mainly where a fourth “maverick” carrier holds at least 5 per cent of a market. Vidéotron has played that role in Quebec for more than a decade, pushing bigger data buckets and lower prices that the big three had to match. The benefits of a fourth competitor are not just borne out by Canadian experience, but internationally.

Using the Global Media and Internet Concentration Project’s 2025 data, I calculated what the deal would do to each market where Telus and Quebecor compete. Nationally, the merged firm would hold 35 per cent of wireless revenue and 38 per cent of subscribers, more than Rogers or Bell. The four largest wireless carriers would control almost 99 per cent of the wireless market. The Herfindahl-Hirschman Index (HHI), another standard measure of concentration, would rise by 408 points on revenue and nearly 600 on subscribers. When Rogers first proposed to buy Shaw, including Freedom, the national increase was 239 points, a figure the Competition Bureau treated as a red flag. The same story would play out across all affected sectors of the telecoms industry, including internet access and broadcasting distribution.

Opinion: A Quebecor-Telus merger would be a problem for the industry – and for democracy

The harm of this deal would be sharpest in regional wireless competition. In Quebec, Vidéotron and Telus together would hold about 46 per cent of the market based on revenue and the HHI would jump by more than 1,000 points, and just half the market by subscriber count. In Alberta, the merged firm would hold more than half the market; in British Columbia, about 45 per cent. In both of these western provinces, Freedom is the challenger Ottawa supported to keep alive the competition with Telus, Rogers and Bell after the Rogers-Shaw takeover. This deal would kill that pledge by turning Telus over to bulked-up Quebecor and dropping the number of competitors from four to three.

Between 2022 and 2024, Parliament overhauled the Competition Act to set thresholds that presume a merger is anti-competitive when it raises the HHI by more than 100 points, leaves the HHI above 1,800 or gives the merged firm more than a 30-per-cent share in affected markets. These changes were partly adopted in response to the realization that the act was no match for the Rogers-Shaw deal. The Quebecor-Telus proposal smashes through all three of those screens in national wireless, in the provincial wireless markets of Quebec, Alberta, B.C. and Ontario, in national internet access (by subscribers) and in cable, IPTV and satellite TV distribution.

Internet access and television distribution tell a similar story. The merged firm would serve about 4.5 million internet subscribers – 28 per cent of the national market and more than either Bell or Rogers. In TV distribution, the top four would control 95 per cent of the market.

The national figures understate the problem because internet competition is local. Most households can choose between two wireline networks: the phone company’s and the cable company’s. After years of setbacks, the CRTC’s 2024 wholesale fibre decision let the big carriers enter each other’s territory. Telus began selling internet service in Ontario and Quebec. Quebecor already had such access in Ontario and Western Canada to Rogers’ networks on account of conditions that gave it ownership of Freedom Mobile, and has asked the regulator to penalize Bell and Telus for hobbling access to their fibre networks.

Opinion: Pierre Karl Péladeau champions Canadian sovereignty to pitch Quebecor takeover of Telus. Really?

Thus, just as the big carriers begin to compete outside their home turf, the merger would end that. In parts of eastern Quebec where Telus is the phone company, it could leave both wireline networks under one owner. And it comes after independent ISPs lost 40 per cent of their subscribers between 2020 and 2024, as the incumbents bought up EBOX, Distributel, VMedia, Start.ca, Oxio and others.

Quebecor promises about $160-million a year in operating savings and $235-million in capital efficiencies. But Parliament removed the efficiencies defence from the Competition Act in 2023 for good reason: cost savings for shareholders do not justify less competition for customers, and nothing would require those savings to show up on anyone’s bill.

The claim that Canada needs a bigger carrier to take on global tech and satellite rivals is equally weak. Starlink holds about 5 per cent of internet access revenue. Telus and Vidéotron compete with Bell and Rogers for Canadians’ phone, internet and TV bills, not with Google. A better remedy is strong communications regulation to counter domestic telecoms and global big tech giants’ dominance of telecoms and digital markets that are both defined by entrenched and sky-high levels of concentration.

For years, my colleagues and I have argued that the defining feature of Canada’s network media economy is the vertical integration of carriers with broadcasters and publishers. Lately, that model has been losing ground to Alphabet, Amazon, Meta and Netflix. This deal would reverse the trend, and the merged firm would rank second in the country, behind Bell and ahead of Rogers, Alphabet and Amazon. Quebecor already owns TVA, the dominant French-language network, the illico+ streaming service, Le Journal de Montréal and Le Journal de Québec, book and music publishing operations, and more. Add Telus, and the share of national media power held by vertically integrated giants (Bell, Rogers and Quebecor-Telus) would jump from about 41 per cent to 54 per cent.

Opinion: Like Rogers-Shaw, a Quebecor-Telus deal needs to sell Freedom, too. But it won’t be enough

Telus shareholders would own about 54 per cent of the combined company but would not control it. Control of a far larger share of the country’s communications infrastructure, and of Quebec’s media, would sit with Quebecor’s controlling shareholder.

The lesson of Bell MTS and of T-Mobile-Sprint in the United States is that regulators should not trade a real competitor for the promise of a future one. In Canada, the decade-long record of progress on prices, adoption and broadband data usage stalled after the Rogers-Shaw deal. There is no Vidéotron waiting in the wings this time.

Parliament’s industry committee should hold hearings now. The Competition Bureau should challenge the deal under the new presumptions rather than negotiate conditions. The Minister of Industry should refuse any spectrum transfer that reduces the country to three national carriers, and the CRTC should protect the wholesale rules that let new rivals in. As we argued about Rogers-Shaw, and in our brief to Parliament, Canada’s problem is too little competition, not too few giants.

Mr. Péladeau was right in 2021. Fewer players means less competition. Parliament and regulators should hold Quebecor to its word.