The Canada Nation

Your Trusted news Source

MTY Food comes under pressure to reopen takeover talks with Foodtastic

MTY Food comes under pressure to reopen takeover talks with Foodtastic



Open this photo in gallery:

Manchu Wok workers prep orders at a food court in Toronto. The company is operated by Foodtastic, which also runs Thai Express, Big Smoke Burger and other chains.Sammy Kogan/The Globe and Mail

Canadian restaurant franchisor MTY Food Group Inc. MTY-T is coming under pressure to reopen takeover talks with rival Foodtastic Inc. as the two companies exchange verbal punches over the best path forward for investors.

Foodtastic, the Montreal-based company behind brands including Milestones, Freshii and Second Cup, went public Tuesday with a $43 per share cash offer for MTY after saying MTY’s board refused to engage in substantive talks. The bid values the company at roughly $1-billion.

On Wednesday, Foodtastic said it was well ahead in its due diligence and suggested it could get a deal done quickly if MTY reopened the door. It said price was the main stumbling block to striking an agreement during previous discussions between the companies.

“The company had unrealistic expectations about its value,” Foodtastic said in a statement. “We call on MTY’s shareholders to voice their perspectives about our proposed transaction to the board and stand ready to engage with the company as soon as possible.”

MTY, whose headquarters is a two-minute drive from Foodtastic’s base, operates the Thai Express, Manchu Wok and Big Smoke Burger banners, among others. The company has struggled to grow the business in recent months and ended a strategic review in October with a decision to go it alone, concluding that the most compelling path forward was to speed up and sharpen its existing strategy.

Foodtastic chief executive Peter Mammas counters that shareholders should take his offer instead. He argues MTY’s strategy equates to a “highly uncertain and unsubstantiated bet” that MTY leaders can turn things around. MTY is better off in the hands of a private owner, he says.

MTY did not immediately respond to a request for comment Wednesday.

The company has cast doubt on Foodtastic’s ability to fund a takeover. In response to Foodtastic’s move to bring its offer into the open, it said Tuesday that its rival has been in the picture for a while as a potential buyer and that during the strategic review, it was offered “multiple extensions of its exclusivity period” to secure financing and close the transaction.

Those comments about financing are “a red herring,” Foodtastic said Wednesday. Shareholders are not being asked to vote on a deal without financing, the company said. Foodtastic is backed by funds managed by Oaktree Capital Management L.P.

MTY has said that when Foodtastic put its offer in writing in mid-October and repeated the same offer five days later, it considered the proposals but concluded it was not in the best interest of the company or its shareholders. It rejected the bid and formally ended discussions with Foodtastic.

Some analysts said MTY should kick-start negotiations again.

“We view the $43 non-binding proposal offered by Foodtastic as a highly credible offer and one that MTY’s board should engage on,” Raymond James analyst Michael Glen said in a research note. He said he does not understand how the offer “can be simply dismissed” on funding concerns.

The offer “probably represents the optimal outcome for MTY shareholders,” Scotiabank analyst John Zamparo said in a separate note, estimating a 60-per-cent probability of a deal at $43 per share. “Though the stock exceeded this price just nine months ago, we consider this the best option for value-creation over the next few years.”

MTY traces its origins back to Hong Kong émigré Stanley Ma, who is currently its chairman and largest shareholder. It has been known historically as a shopping mall food court consolidator, but it has morphed over time: About three-quarters of its restaurant system sales now come from free-standing restaurants such as Baton Rouge, Barrio Queen, and Pizza Delight.