A payment terminal displays suggested tip amounts of 15, 18 and 20 per cent. Unlike Canada, where tipping prompts are widespread, many British restaurants add an optional service charge of about 12 per cent to the bill.Ryan Remiorz/The Canadian Press
Canadians have been sounding off about tipping for years. And while solutions have been in short supply, the angst keeps growing.
A petition this month to “end tip culture in Canada” has already gathered tens of thousands of signatures. It calls for governments and regulators to step in with stricter oversight around exploitative tipping practices and improved protections for services staff wages.
But on a trip to London this week, I encountered another possible solution: a flat optional service charge.
The fee – about 12 per cent in most London eateries – is relatively standard across restaurants and is labelled on the bill as “optional service charge.” You can still get rid of it, but you’d have to opt out.
I’ll preface by saying that not all Brits are big fans of this measure. Understandably so, as it’s often seen as a compromise to what came before it.
Not long ago, tips in the country were rare. Adrian Martin, head of the University of Essex’s Edge Hotel School and a hospitality researcher, said one in five people across his study saw tipping as mostly obligatory.
The arrival of U.S.-dominated point of sale systems is threatening to change that, however. A wave of recent headlines have sounded the alarm over the possibility of U.S tipping customs, where an 18- to 20-per-cent gratuity is increasingly the norm, creeping into London restaurants, cafes and worst of all, the pub.
Canada is often overlooked in these discussions, but those same tipping norms exist here, despite the fact that earnings for service staff more closely resemble those in the U.K., with both countries having largely scrapped the bare-bones tipping wage that prevails across most U.S. states.
American payment software, such as billion-dollar processing and point-of-sale company Square, dominates in Canada too. Even Canadian player Moneris, a major exception to that rule, announced this year it was getting bought by a U.S. company.
And while Canadian businesses now match U.S. norms, along with their payment technology, the U.K. hasn’t followed just yet.
Hospitality businesses across the pond are leaning on the relatively standardized optional service fee. During my trip to the U.K., the optional charge was added at most London restaurants – not cafes and fast-food shops, as is often the case in Canada. It’s becoming the norm in major cities across England, according to Mr. Martin.
His data shows that service charges across U.K. restaurants averaged about 11.8 per cent of the bill – still a lot lower than in Canada. They were added during 6 per cent of visits at the most casual restaurants and 55 per cent of those in fine dining.
“Optional service charges can be a sensible middle ground,” said Mr. Martin. And they offer somewhat of a win-win for businesses and customers in terms of savings.
Unless you’re a frequent tip-skipper, the service charge generally lets you play less overall because you’re never paying 18 to 20 per cent just because you clicked the default option, felt confused or ambushed.
Servers, meanwhile, benefit because the system evens out the big tippers and the low or no-tippers.
For staff, oftentimes, a tip is “largely a matter of luck,” Mr. Martin said. Service charges replace that luck with a more predictable payment.
It goes without saying that this scheme works best when there are guarantees that gratuity is passed to staff in full, as U.K. law now requires, and when customers are clearly informed about the charge so they don’t end up tipping twice without realizing.
So what would you prefer? An optional– but automatically included – service charge, or a menu of prompts to choose from set by the business?
Drop me a line at mpostelnyak@globeandmail.com.
Subscribe to the On Money newsletter
Mariya’s consumer reading list
Homeowners testing the waters in Canada’s largest city are facing an increasingly sobering wake-up call when trying to sell. Valery Real Estate Inc. data showed that 80 per cent of homes sold in the Greater Toronto Area this past year got less than their owners paid for them between 2021-22, amounting to almost $1-billion in losses.
What are heat-seeking snowbirds tired of Donald Trump’s 51st state tirades doing instead of heading to Florida? Just about anything else. This piece closely follows nine people who sold their U.S. condos, pulled up stakes and headed for warmer shores far from our next-door neighbours.
Next Stress Test podcast drops: A guide to housing regret
Should you stay or should you sell? For years, buying a home in Canada seemed like one of the surest ways for young people to build wealth. The plan was simple: When your first home no longer fit your needs, you could sell at a tidy profit and move somewhere more suitable.
But home prices have fallen from their peaks, while higher interest rates and carrying costs have left many owners with less equity and fewer options than they expected. Rob Carrick speaks with certified financial planner Jason Heath about how much the housing market has changed, the risks of betting on a rebound in home prices and why going back to renting isn’t necessarily a financial failure.
Chart of the day
In this chart, Fred Vettese explains that Old Age Security pensions are shrinking, which means young Canadians will need to save more for retirement.
Financial Tool
Ahead of the winter travel surge, Google Maps is launching a new AI trip-planning tool that lets you create custom itineraries with advice such as what roads to take and agentic bots that book your dinner reservations.
More Stories
Ottawa to purchase credits from carbon-removal startups to offset its emissions
Lutnick, who sank U.S.-Canada deal, becomes White House’s Nvidia fall guy. Feels good?
BMO returns to U.S. oil, gas investment banking, source says