The Canada Nation

Your Trusted news Source

Banking regulator aims to level playing field between small and big banks

Banking regulator aims to level playing field between small and big banks



Open this photo in gallery:

OSFI Superintendent Peter Routledge, pictured in Ottawa in 2023, says the regulatory changes target the largest lending categories at smaller banks.Dave Chan/The Globe and Mail

Canada’s banking regulator is easing capital requirements for lending at small and medium-sized banks in a bid to level the playing field with the biggest banks as Ottawa takes aim at competition in the sector.

The Office of the Superintendent of Financial Institutions (OSFI) unveiled a suite of regulatory changes Thursday targetting the country’s highly concentrated banking industry. The updates follow the tabling of Ottawa’s federal budget, which gives the regulator a new mandate to oversee competition and innovation.

OSFI said it will lower capital intensity for lending by small and medium-sized banks, including federal credit unions. The change will apply to select asset classes, including residential mortgages, small and medium-sized business lending, and corporate lending.

OSFI Superintendent Peter Routledge said these are the largest lending categories at the smaller banks, and that targetted changes to these asset classes would make the biggest impact in remedying competitive imbalances with big banks.

For residential mortgages, OSFI is lowering risk weighed asset rules for smaller institutions and introducing preferential treatment for mortgages with credit-bureau scores above 720, which includes the vast majority of residential mortgage borrowers in Canada.

Risk weightings – the different levels of risk assigned to certain types of bank loans – determine the amount of capital a bank must reserve against its loan portfolio. That influences decisions about how much banks lend and to whom.

For example, Mr. Routledge said a borrower with a 750 credit score would get two very different quotes from a small and big bank because the smaller institution would need to allocate two to three times the amount of capital for that loan compared to the larger lender.

“You’re the same person to either bank. Why are we having that large an imbalance in capital required for that particular loan to that particular customer?” Mr. Routledge said in an interview.

”In that sense, we thought that was a reasonable argument that competitive imbalance was too great to sustain, and that we could lessen it without materially impacting credit quality and, therefore, prudential health in the system.”

Financial regulator to implement tighter guardrails on banks’ use of AI

OSFI also lowered risk weightings for small and medium-sized business loans from 85 per cent to 75 per cent. For corporate loans, risk weightings will fall from 100 per cent to 80 per cent.

Ottawa has taken a keen interest in boosting competition in banking in recent years. Canada’s banking industry is dominated by six lenders – Royal Bank of Canada RY-T, Toronto-Dominion Bank TD-T, Bank of Nova Scotia BNS-T, Bank of Montreal BMO-T, Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce CM-T and National Bank of Canada NA-T – that hold more than 90-per-cent market share.

In the budget released earlier this month, the federal government said it will amend the law that governs OSFI to add a “secondary competition objective” to its mandate. OSFI’s current mandate focuses on maintaining a stable and sound financial system.

For several years, OSFI has been hearing feedback from industry stakeholders and small banks and credit unions on competitive issues with capital requirements, Mr. Routledge said. Considering that Canadian financial institutions withstood the impact of a series of bank failures in the United States in recent years, Mr. Routledge said the regulator realized it could offer some slack in the system.

The changes also come as Canadians and Ottawa press for more competition in banking, Mr. Routledge said.

“There is clear will of the Canadian people to have a more competitive financial sector, including in banking, and we’re listening to that,” Mr. Routledge said.

Opinion: Carney boldly strikes at the heart of Canada’s antiquated banking system

OSFI’s latest move is part of a broader initiative to make regulatory changes that could introduce more competition into the market. OSFI said it intends to make requirements more proportionate, reduce unnecessary regulatory burden, and support the entry of new competitors to the financial system.

Banks are required to hold a certain amount of capital as a buffer against an economic downturn. OSFI proposed changes to the capital adequacy requirements guideline for small and medium-sized banks to boost capacity for risk-taking and improve the competitive balance between the small and large banks.

OSFI is also considering changes to its capital framework to better align requirements with underlying risks, including lowering capital levels for government-sponsored venture capital fund investments. Instead of a 400-per-cent risk weighting for those equity investments, banks will have to hold a 100-per-cent risk weighting, making them more attractive opportunities.

That should encourage banks to consider government-sponsored venture capital fund investments, and “support more investment in Canada at a time when you know the shift in our economy is going to require equity as well as credit investment,” Mr. Routledge said.

Over the past year, the regulator has made tweaks to various capital requirements. In June, OSFI reduced the size of the capital cushion the big banks must hold, freeing up billions of dollars to encourage lending. It also lowered capital requirements for loans for certain corporate and real estate properties to build lending capacity.