The Canada Nation

Your Trusted news Source

Anthropic’s and other mega IPOs threaten big banks’ underwriting game

Anthropic’s and other mega IPOs threaten big banks’ underwriting game



Open this photo in gallery:

CEO of Anthropic Dario Amodei, addresses the gathering at the AI Impact Summit, in New Delhi, India, Feb. 19. On lockups, Anthropic has gone further than SpaceX did, with 315 million shares not subject to a lockup at all.Bhawika Chhabra/Reuters

J. Ari Pandes is an associate professor of finance and an associate dean at the University of Calgary’s Haskayne School of Business. He is also a research fellow at the C.D. Howe Institute.

Jay R. Ritter is the Joseph B. Cordell Eminent Scholar Chair Emeritus and the director of the IPO Initiative at the University of Florida’s Warrington College of Business.

Anthropic PBC is expected to start trading on Thursday in what is the largest initial public offering ever, at a valuation of more than US$1-trillion. Remarkable for a company less than six years old.

Buried on page 318 of its preliminary prospectus is something we have not seen before in a major IPO. It says that as many as 315 million Class A shares held by existing shareholders can be sold in the market the moment trading starts, rather than being locked up for months, as in a typical IPO.

Those shares are not part of the offering. They will be sold at whatever price the market sets rather than at the offer price. As opposed to the IPO shares, no commission will be paid to the underwriting banks on these 315 million Class A shares, and the banks will not decide who is allowed to buy them.

Anthropic prices IPO at $83 a share, clinches biggest stock-market debut on record

To see why that matters, consider how the banks taking a company public normally get paid. In a previous opinion piece, we noted that SpaceX was especially aggressive in negotiating a low commission, known as the gross spread, paid to the banks taking it public. Notably, it paid only 0.666 per cent of the money raised and negotiated a 0 per cent gross spread on overallotment shares, which are the extra shares that banks are entitled to sell. That reduced the average spread it paid to banks down to only 0.58 per cent. Still, that amounted to US$500-million, split among the 22 banks involved in the deal.

SpaceX also took an unusually active role in the allocation of shares, a decision normally made by the “lead-left” underwriter, which is the bank listed on the left side of the top row of the prospectus cover. That bank tends to favour its most profitable clients, many of which are hedge funds, whereas issuers prefer that most shares go to buy-and-hold investors – which SpaceX succeeded in doing with its IPO.

We previously asked whether Anthropic would be similarly aggressive in negotiating a low gross spread and taking an active role in allocating shares. On the gross spread, it appears not, even though the spread will not be set until the offering price is decided the day before trading begins. Anthropic is expected to pay a commission on its overallotment shares, whereas SpaceX paid none, and its total fees may exceed SpaceX’s record US$500-million.

Anthropic IPO brings raft of new products for Canadian investors

On lockups, though, Anthropic has gone further than SpaceX did, with 315 million shares not subject to a lockup at all.

In some countries, shares not included in the IPO are required by regulators to be locked up. In the U.S., and for large issuers in Canada, lockups are not mandatory, but they are ubiquitous. We are not aware of any major issuer conducting a traditional IPO where the banks involved have agreed to forgo a lockup for some of the pre-IPO shares that are not being sold at the offer price.

The banks get nothing from these 315 million shares that are not locked up. If they were included in the IPO, the lead-left underwriter could allocate them to its favoured clients and the banks would collect a commission on each share sold. Instead, those unlocked shares will compete with the shares that the banks sell.

Direct listings, in which a company goes public without an underwritten offering, also provide insiders the ability to sell shares on day one, but they never unseated the traditional IPO. One reason is that banks had little incentive to recommend a structure that paid them far less – and they had the market power to steer issuers away from it. Now, the Anthropic IPO suggests that this feature could become part of the traditional IPO for issuers with enough sway.

It looks as though SpaceX and Anthropic have each used their enormous size to threaten the business model of the big banks that dominate IPOs. SpaceX, in its offering, drove a hard bargain on the gross spreads and how shares are allocated. Anthropic is driving a hard bargain on lockups, with 315 million shares permitted to be sold immediately at the market price, carrying no underwriting commission. It will be interesting to see whether OpenAI’s IPO, if and when it comes, reflects these precedents.