The Canada Nation

Your Trusted news Source

My work shift was cancelled but no one told me. Should I still get paid?

My work shift was cancelled but no one told me. Should I still get paid?



Interested in more careers-related content? Check out our new weekly Work Life newsletter. Sent every Monday afternoon.

THE QUESTION

I recently started as a support worker at a small private school. The position is five days a week during school hours but there was a PA day and no one told me about it. I only found out when I showed up at the school and the kids weren’t there and they said I could go home. I’m obviously not getting paid for that day but it seems unfair that no one told me I didn’t have to be at work, especially when I could have picked up a shift at my second job. Is this allowed? Should the school owe me any money for showing up when no one gave me notice that there was no work that day?

THE FIRST ANSWER

Ryan Edmonds, managing lawyer and Thulasi Kandiah, associate lawyer, Ryan Edmonds Workplace Counsel, Toronto

You have every reason to be frustrated. Schools generally know their PA days well in advance and making sure employees know when they are expected to work should not be difficult.

There are two issues here: whether the school was required to give you notice of the PA day and whether it owes you any money.

In Ontario, the Employment Standards Act does not require employers to provide advance notice of a cancelled shift. Your employment agreement may provide otherwise, but by default, the school’s failure to notify you is not necessarily unlawful.

However, Ontario has what is commonly referred to as the “three-hour rule.” If you regularly work more than three hours a day, are required to report for work and are available to work but are sent home early, your employer generally must pay you for at least three hours at your regular rate.

If you were expected to work that day and had never been told otherwise, you should be entitled to three hours’ pay, even though you performed no work.

There is, however, an important caveat to the “three-hour rule”. If it had been previously communicated to you that you would not work on PA days, for example, and this is stated in your employment agreement or referenced in a school calendar, then the “three-hour rule” may not apply, even if nobody reminded you. This is because the “three-hour rule” is meant to compensate for the inconvenience of being sent home after being required to report to work.

As for your second job, while the lost opportunity to earn additional income is understandably frustrating, the school is unlikely to be responsible for wages you might have earned elsewhere.

Potential legal entitlements aside, this is really a matter of basic workplace courtesy and communication. If the school is unwilling to provide you with three hours of pay, then you should at least be given a clear schedule of upcoming PA days and school closures.

THE SECOND ANSWER

Muneeza Sheikh, founding partner, Muneeza Sheikh Employment and Human Rights, Toronto

Given that you work full-time at five days a week, it is entirely reasonable to assume that you would be informed by the school if there was a day that you would not have work. The school has an obligation to keep you informed of PA days, so you can, as you say, make plans to take the day off or work at another job. It is my view that if the school failed to communicate the PA day to you, there would be a legal obligation to pay you for the day of work.

With that being said, I am wondering what steps the school took to communicate the PA day to staff. Was it something that was discussed, posted or circulated and perhaps you just missed it? Were you provided with a list of scheduled PA days at the time of hire? If they did none of the above, I think it is entirely reasonable for you to be asked to be paid for that day. If you missed the chance to work elsewhere through no fault of your own, it is something that the school should be responsible for unless they can prove they did nothing wrong.

If after speaking to the school, they can demonstrate that you ought to have known about the PA day, they would owe you nothing. If they refuse to pay you despite being responsible for the lack of communication, you can certainly retain a lawyer to demand payment on your behalf or perhaps take the case before your local ministry of labour. In my practice, where similar issues have arisen, I have seen employees who make the choice to forego the issue and put the employer on warning that nothing like this can happen again, although it is your right to demand payment.

Have a question for our experts? Send an e-mail to NineToFive@globeandmail.com with ‘Nine to Five’ in the subject line. E-mails without the correct subject line may not be answered.