Industry Minister Mélanie Joly, shown in Hamilton last Friday, opted to use the word ‘sovereignty’ or ‘sovereign’ three times in a brief statement on the potential Quebecor-Telus marriage.Carlos Osorio/Reuters
Three short years ago, the federal government had one response to a telecom takeover that reshaped the sector: How would Rogers Communications Inc.’s blockbuster bid for Shaw Communications Inc. benefit consumers?
On Monday, Industry Minister Mélanie Joly spoke a whole new language to signal Ottawa’s response to Quebecor Inc.’s QBR-B-T even more audacious $31-billion proposal to acquire Telus Corp. T-T
Ms. Joly, speaking for a Prime Minister who coined the term “rupture in the world order,” opted to use the word “sovereignty” or “sovereign” three times in a brief statement on the potential marriage of Quebecor and Telus.
While Ms. Joly flagged affordability and cost-of-living pressures as issues any telecom transaction must address – not just one involving Quebecor – she also talked about building resiliency “in a period of great geopolitical and technological change.”
At no point did Ms. Joly mention the concept of preserving four domestic wireless platforms as the solution to rising cellphone bills.
That pro-competition policy guided her predecessor François-Philippe Champagne’s approach to the Rogers acquisition of Shaw. Ottawa allowed Quebecor to vault from regional player to the national stage by acquiring Shaw’s Freedom Mobile wireless business.
On Monday, Quebecor chief executive Pierre Karl Péladeau also signalled that this vast, sparsely populated country cannot support four cellphone carriers that expect to make acceptable returns.
Quebecor faces significant investments on infrastructure over the next decade, as the cost of piggybacking on other telecoms’ networks rises and a sweetheart deal to share Rogers equipment expires.
Quebecor chief executive Pierre Karl Péladeau, shown in Toronto on Monday, pitched the merits of a Telus deal in meetings with government officials last week.Cole Burston/The Globe and Mail
Rather than spend billions on his own gear, Mr. Péladeau is using Quebecor shares that trade at a premium as currency to buy a Telus network that trades at a discount.
Mr. Péladeau spent last week in Ottawa, pitching government officials including Ms. Joly and Clerk of the Privy Council Michael Sabia on the merits of a Telus deal. (For those with short memories, Mr. Sabia is the former CEO of Bell Canada parent BCE Inc.)
The sessions focused on sovereignty and the need for domestic telecoms that can compete with Elon Musk’s Starlink, Mr. Péladeau said in an interview on Monday. He said the politicians listened intently and made no promises. Clearly, no one in Ottawa threw up a stop sign.
To give Mr. Péladeau his due, he has built Quebecor by being the consumer’s champion. The company won market share from Montreal-based rival BCE, then from Telus and Rogers, by consistently offering the lowest prices on cellphone and internet services. Quebecor’s CEO said he promised to keep that strategy in place if he wins Vancouver-based Telus.
Quebecor began its courtship of Telus in late June, just as CEO Victor Dodig took the reins. The former CIBC boss is cleaning out the stables, selling predecessor Darren Entwistle’s science projects in health care and agriculture and cutting the dividend as he shifts the company’s focus back to telecom.
Mr. Dodig also spent an interview on Monday talking about sovereignty. He said Canada needs robust domestic players in a telecom sector that is essential to a modern economy. Mr. Dodig said Telus has “serious concerns with every element of Quebecor’s proposal.”
Telus pulls out of two planned Vancouver AI data centres
Mr. Dodig had a specific issue with Mr. Péladeau’s potential control of the combined company through Quebecor’s dual-share structure.
The terms of Quebecor’s cash-and-shares proposal mean Telus shareholders would hold a 54-per-cent economic interest and 23 per cent of the votes in the combined company. Mr. Dodig said: “That doesn’t work.”
What will work?
Ms. Joly, who has made no secret of her ambition for an Ottawa job one tier above being a minister, is cleverly signalling that the government is open to a telecom transaction that ticks a great many boxes. They include sovereignty and affordability. The minister also left herself an out, making it clear the government will turn down any deal that doesn’t serve the national interest.
If the federal government no longer believes four national cellphone platforms are necessary, the logical tie-up isn’t between Quebecor and Telus.
The marriage made in heaven in telecom circles is BCE getting together with Telus. They share networks and scale that would make the combined company – call it Belus – a national champion. In 2007, the two companies flirted with a union.
When Quebecor came calling, Telus’s board started a strategic review that includes looking at other partners. Mr. Dodig said the company “will leave no rock unturned” as it negotiates with Mr. Péladeau, whom he is meeting with later this month.
A union of BCE and Telus would mean divesting cellphone and internet customers to win regulators’ blessings. Quebecor would be the natural buyer, as Rogers already holds significant market share.
Mr. Péladeau is on a path to win, even if he loses Telus.
More Stories
Competition Bureau does not penalize Express Scripts, but raises concern about exclusive pharmacy deals
At Nvidia, a strongman leader who did as he liked. Seen this before?
United Airlines suffers widespread system outage just days after U.S. ground stop