Quebecor CEO Pierre Karl Péladeau.Fred Lum/The Globe and Mail
Quebecor Inc. QBR-B-T, Canada’s fourth-largest telecom company, is making a $31-billion proposal to acquire rival Telus Corp. T-T, a takeover that would remake the cellphone sector and pose the second major test of the federal government’s competition law in the past five years.
Montreal-based Quebecor, led by media and telecom mogul Pierre Karl Péladeau, has made a non-binding proposal to acquire Telus, headquartered in Vancouver, for $19.45 in cash and stock, after the share price of the dominant telecom in western Canada slid by more than 40 per cent over the past year.
Quebecor’s proposal represents a 60-per-cent premium to Telus’s share price on Friday. Combining the two companies would support long-term investment and affordable telecom rates in Canada, Mr. Péladeau said in a press release.
In a statement, Telus said it has formed a special committee of independent directors and has engaged financial and legal advisers to review the proposal, but to date has surfaced a number of significant risks associated with it.
“Four months after its initial proposal, Québecor has yet to explain how what it is proposing could be approved under the current telecom regulatory framework,” said Telus board chair John Manley in a release Monday morning. Such a review would be a long and costly process for shareholders, he said.
Any such deal would require approval from Canada’s competition watchdog, several government agencies and federal Industry Minister Mélanie Joly. Combining two of the country’s four dominant cellphone providers would mean the federal government breaks with a consumer-friendly policy of encouraging competition in the cellphone industry by pushing for four national players.
Under Quebecor’s proposal, Telus shareholders would receive $6.35 in cash and 0.17 Quebecor shares for each Telus share, which it says would represent approximately $19.45 per share, compared a closing price of $12.14 on the Toronto Stock Exchange last Friday. It said it would expect to maintain its current dividend of $1.80 per share.
Quebecor’s $31-billion equity calculation is based on 1.6 billion fully diluted Telus shares outstanding. When adding Telus’s net debt of $29.6-billion, this implies an enterprise value of $60.6-billion.
If the deal goes forward, Telus shareholders would hold approximately 54 per cent economic interest and 23 per cent of the votes in the combined company, Quebecor said in financial documents released Monday morning. Mr. Péladeau’s family controls Quebecor through a dual-share structure that would continue to exist if the company acquired Telus.
Telus said the proposed governance structure raises significant concerns. “The proposal would result in Québecor gaining control of a combined entity in which TELUS shareholders would contribute the majority of the economic value while receiving a minority voting position.”
Moreover, Telus shareholders would be asked to accept equity in a materially more leveraged enterprise, it added. “A highly levered combined company would be less able to invest in its business.”
Meanwhile, it said that as the proposal contemplates a fixed exchange ratio per share, “any premium implied by Québecor’s proposal may differ materially from the value ultimately received by TELUS shareholders.”
At the same time, Mr. Manley said the committee is exploring “other strategic initiatives” to maximize value. That could include maintaining the status quo.
Quebecor is hoping Telus shareholders may welcome the opportunity to win back lost ground. Recently, the Vancouver telecom has struggled under the weight of significant debt accrued through network build-outs and acquisitions as well as concerns from investors about future growth, even after a 50-per-cent dividend cut earlier this year.
Since becoming chief executive officer on July 1, Victor Dodig has laid out plans for the company to deleverage, a strategy which includes selling off major assets and focusing on the core telecom business.
Quebecor said it first approached Telus in late June, just before Mr. Dodig replaced long-serving CEO Darren Entwistle, with a non-binding proposal which it described as a “basis for negotiations,” and subsequently responded to questions put forward by Telus.
On Friday, Quebecor submitted an “enhanced proposal,” which it said Telus is now reviewing. The proposal was not requested, agreed to or endorsed by the Telus’s board, according Quebecor’s documents.
The Quebec company said it has invited Telus’s board to execute confidentiality agreements so they can proceed with negotiations, but chose to make the process public so that “all stakeholders can assess the value of its proposal.”
Quebecor is making its pitch after its stock market performance has significantly outpaced that of rivals and given the telecom a premium valuation.
The company has seen major success in its attempts to win subscribers from Canada’s three largest incumbents since acquiring Freedom Mobile in 2023, after offering competitive plans which also drove down rivals’ prices. Investor optimism has fuelled a 47-per-cent increase in its share price over the last year.
Quebecor shares closed Friday at $77 on the Toronto Stock Exchange, with a total market capitalization of $17.4-billion, compared to Telus’s $19.3-billion.
Quebecor is arguing the combined entity would preserve sovereign control of strategic communication assets, and drive nearly $400-million annually in operating and capital efficiencies, which would allow it to invest in networks, artificial intelligence and data centres.
But any such deal will face intense scrutiny from Canada’s Competition Bureau, which launched a fierce opposition to Rogers Communications Inc.’s $20-billion takeover of Shaw Communications Inc.
Ultimately, that deal was approved, and Quebecor was able to use Ottawa’s four-player policy to acquire cellphone service Freedom Mobile for $2.85-billion, a sale that Rogers had to make in order to win federal government approval for its purchase of Calgary-based Shaw.
But the takeover led to changes to the Competition Act that introduced barriers to another such deal.
For instance, in 2023, the Canadian government abolished the efficiencies defence, a clause which previously prevented the Tribunal from blocking a merger in which the efficiency gains outweighed the anti-competitive effects. The following year, the government introduced “structural presumptions,” legal rules that presume that high market shares are inherently harmful to consumers and that mergers that significantly increase concentration are anti-competitive.
While Quebecor owns significant internet infrastructure in Quebec, its expansion of Freedom Mobile has largely leaned on its use of Canada’s network sharing framework, which requires other companies to allow Quebecor to resell service over their networks at mandated rates. The company’s access to those rates is set to expire in 2030.
In its release, Quebecor acknowledged the transaction would be subject to approval by the relevant authorities – the Bureau, as well as the Canadian Radio-television and Telecommunications Commission, and Innovation, Science and Economic Development Canada.
The company said it has engaged competition experts, and is prepared to discuss “measurable commitments regarding pricing, regional connectivity, innovation and employment,” including maintaining Telus’s head office in Vancouver.
Quebecor is also framing the takeover as a means of providing the scale necessary to take on global technology and satellite players that are expanding their presence in Canada, before those companies “become entrenched.”
American streaming giants such as Netflix have eroded Canadian viewership of linear television services provided by companies such as Quebecor. Meanwhile, Elon Musk’s Starlink has made headways into Canada with its satellite internet service, and is moving to offer cellphone service directly to customers in the U.S.
With files from Andrew Willis
More Stories
Ranking Canada’s airline loyalty programs and top-pick flies
Proposed emergency earthquake fund will help prepare for catastrophe, insurance industry says
Carney boldly strikes at the heart of Canada’s antiquated banking system