Prime Minister Mark Carney arrives in the House of Commons on Parliament Hill before the tabling of the federal budget in Ottawa, on Nov. 5.Justin Tang/The Canadian Press
John Turley-Ewart is a contributing columnist for The Globe and Mail, a regulatory compliance consultant and a Canadian banking historian.
It hasn’t sunk in yet. The talk of missing the mark, sparking more questions than answers, ignoring affordability for the young and compounding the country’s debt has obscured the historic shift contained within Prime Minister Mark Carney’s Nov. 5 budget.
Mr. Carney intends to fundamentally alter a critical aspect of Canada’s economic infrastructure – its banking system.
Arcane proposals included in the budget (launching real-time rail payments, new pilot projects using digital credentials, the issuance of stablecoins) are sideshows. Meaningful measures to increase bank competition signal a government willing to test a century of Canada’s Finance Department prioritizing bank stability over competition and growth.
Today’s banking system is an outcome of that past. Mr. Carney is proposing that tomorrow’s be the outcome of economic ambition. It will take political resolve.
Mr. Carney’s budget strikes at the heart of the overly cautious ethos that has guided bank inspection since 1925, securing stability above all else. It was born of an era when many Canadian banks failed, deposit insurance didn’t exist, competition was suspect and bank mergers solved all problems.
Opinion: Carney made a big, bold $150-billion budget bet. Will it pay off?
The Office of the Superintendent of Financial Institutions, or OSFI, will no longer be simply measured by its contribution to public confidence in our banks. Success, as this budget indicates, will also mean that “competition considerations, such as proportionality, compliance burden, and market impacts, are more clearly and consistently reflected in how OSFI regulates and supervises financial institutions.”
Those changes should curtail regulatory adventurism – OSFI exercising its grip on the Canadian banking system with regulations that keep new banks at bay, that leave existing banks less competitive on the global stage, that limit lending to small, medium and large businesses and that make it harder for consumers to qualify for loans and mortgages.
Pointing to the absence of bank failures, as the current OSFI Superintendent Peter Routledge is prone to doing, while ignoring the constraints on competition and economic growth, won’t do.
For competition to become a defining feature of Canada’s financial landscape, it needs to better welcome new players to the field. To that end, the budget encourages “the entry and growth of mid-sized challenger banks by amending the Bank Act to permit greater flexibility on ownership structures.”
Making it easier to be a bank is helpful, yet the most fundamental step taken by Mr. Carney to support competition and small and mid-sized banks is his decision to modernize the Canadian deposit insurance framework.
Opinion: What happened to restraint?
Currently, the Canada Deposit Insurance Corporation, or CDIC, insures eligible deposits up to $100,000 at member institutions, which include chartered banks, federally regulated credit unions, and loan and trust companies.
That coverage will be increased to $250,000, a move that is long overdue (the last time CDIC coverage was increased was in 2005). Its influence will be significant.
For small and mid-sized banks, customer anxiety about losing deposits caps growth, increases costs and gives OSFI reason to regulate them with a heavier hand for the sake of customers who do trust them with deposits exceeding $100,000.
Interestingly, the budget also promises higher deposit insurance coverage for “certain life events, such as the sale of a home,” and will provide unlimited coverage for deposits in registered and tax-free accounts.
These moves will give Canadians more confidence to trust their savings with small and mid-sized banks as well as new entrants.
For Canada, this promises a brave new banking world – and brave it will need to be. Unlike any reforms to banking in Canada in recent memory, Mr. Carney’s budget changes OSFI’s scorecard and the funding economics for small to mid-sized banks.
Opinion: A budget with more questions than answers
Importantly, by increasing CDIC coverage, he gives small to mid-sized banks better access to sticky, lower-cost deposits the Big Six banks typically attract because of the implicit too-big-to-fail assumption they operate under.
These changes promise better outcomes (more competition and consumer choice) and difficult ones as well.
Within this new banking framework, the likelihood of smaller and mid-sized banks failing increases. History tells us so. And Canadians have not responded well to bank failures in the past, treating them as regulatory failures versus the management failures they most often turn out to be.
The result has been political pressure to revisit the past, prizing stability over innovation, competition and growth.
Passing these proposed changes to Canadian banking into law will be the easy part of the process. Escaping the grip of Canada’s past and a preference for stability over all else will be the hard political work.
More Stories
Nvidia CEO’s resignation pushes investors to measure AI exposure
Chinese automakers view their investments in Hungary as possible model for Canada
Foodtastic’s proposed $1-billion takeover of MTY gains investor support, company says